All About Swimming Pools Journal Today

Pool Removal vs. Pool Demolition: Making the Right Choice for Your Backyard

Feb 5

A swimming pool can be a fantastic addition to any home, providing a source of relaxation and entertainment for families and friends. However, there may come a time when you find yourself contemplating whether it's time for a change in your backyard oasis. Perhaps the pool has fallen into disrepair, is too expensive to maintain, or simply doesn't suit your lifestyle anymore. In such cases, two common options emerge: pool removal and pool demolition. In this blog, we'll explore the differences between these two processes and help you make the right choice for your specific needs.

Pool Removal

Pool removal is a method of eliminating an existing swimming pool while preserving the property's structural integrity and aesthetics. It's an ideal option for homeowners who want to reclaim their outdoor space without compromising the overall appeal of their landscape.

Here's how the pool removal process typically works:

  1. Drain the pool: The first step involves draining the water from the pool, ensuring that it is completely empty.
  2. Demolish the top layer: Once the water is removed, the top layer of the pool (often the concrete or gunite shell) is broken up using heavy machinery or jackhammers.
  3. Fill the pool: After the top layer is demolished, the pool is filled with a combination of soil, gravel, and other suitable materials to ensure proper drainage and stability.
  4. Compact and grade the area: The filled area is compacted to prevent settling and then graded to match the surrounding landscape.

Advantages of Pool Removal:

  1. Enhanced property aesthetics: Pool removal allows you to transform the space into a more visually appealing and functional area for landscaping, gardening, or even building structures like a patio, deck, or additional room.
  2. Cost-effective: While pool removal can be an investment, it typically costs less than a complete pool demolition and is more budget-friendly in the long run since it eliminates ongoing maintenance costs.
  3. Increased property value: Removing a pool can increase your property's value by making it more attractive to potential buyers who may not want the responsibility of maintaining a pool.

Pool Demolition

Pool demolition, on the other hand, involves completely destroying the pool and removing all its components. This option is suitable when the pool is beyond repair or if you prefer a clean slate for a new project on your property.

Here's how the pool demolition process typically works:

  1. Drain the pool: Like in pool removal, the first step is to drain all the water from the pool.
  2. Full demolition: Pool demolition involves breaking down the entire structure, including the concrete shell, plumbing, and other components. Heavy machinery and specialized equipment are used for this purpose.
  3. Hauling away debris: Once the pool is fully demolished, all the debris is removed from the property. This can be done through excavation and transport to a landfill or recycling center.
  4. Fill the space: Similar to pool removal, the space is filled with suitable materials, compacted, and graded to ensure proper drainage.

Advantages of Pool Demolition:

  1. Complete removal: Pool demolition provides a clean slate, eliminating any trace of the former pool. This option is preferred when you want to build a new structure, like a house or garage, in place of the pool.
  2. No ongoing maintenance: Since the pool is completely gone, there are no maintenance costs associated with it, making it a suitable choice for homeowners looking to reduce long-term expenses.

Choosing the Right Option

The decision between pool removal and pool demolition ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. Here are some factors to consider:

  1. Future plans: If you have a clear vision for the space, such as creating a lush garden or expanding your living area, pool removal may be the best choice. However, if you plan to build a new structure in place of the pool, pool demolition is the way to go.
  2. Budget: Consider your budget and the ongoing costs associated with pool maintenance. Pool removal is typically more cost-effective in the long run.
  3. Environmental impact: Both options have environmental considerations. Pool removal is generally less disruptive to the landscape, while pool demolition can create more waste. Be sure to consult with professionals who can help minimize the environmental impact of your choice.
  4. Local regulations: Check with your local authorities about any regulations or permits required for pool removal or demolition in your area.


In the debate between pool removal and pool demolition, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The choice depends on your unique circumstances, future plans, and budget. Both options have their advantages, and consulting with professionals experienced in pool removal and demolition can help you make an informed decision. Whether you choose to rejuvenate your backyard with a pool removal or create a blank canvas with a pool demolition, the transformation of your outdoor space will undoubtedly breathe new life into your home.


Optimal Earth Work    

3070 Garden Ave, San Jose, CA 95111    

(408) 603-3805